Cultural Landscapes Blog

A digital platform which seeks to highlight research, to engage practitioners from the field, to showcase best practices, and contribute to discussions.

Cultural Landscapes BlogThe landscape approach

The landscape approach

4 October 2016/by Jurgen Tack, Julianna Nagy, Sarah McCarthy, Paul Tabbush/Tags: ELC, WHC, landscape approach, landscape labelling, landscape stewardship, landscape resilience

While the European Landscape Convention (ELC) has attracted attention from the sciences, policy makers and the general public to the nature of cultural landscapes, more needs to be done to implement it.
The landscape approach

Work Package 9 partners created a document that sets out the landscape approach towards policy-making advocated by the consortium and makes specific recommendations related to:
- Landscape labelling
- Landscape stewardship
- Landscape resilience to climate change

These policy recommendations are based on the outcomes of the research and the interactions with local stakeholders undertaken by the HERCULES Project.

As a European project, HERCULES based its approach on the definition of landscape within the ELC: “an area, as perceived by people, whose character is the result of the action and interaction of natural and/or human factors”. At the heart of the ELC therefore is the premise that all places – be they natural, rural, urban and marine – are cultural landscapes, and they are inherently dynamic. Thus the ELC does not discriminate between or among landscapes of different value, and affords equal status to ‘ordinary landscapes’ and ‘designated landscapes’ alike.

The ELC therefore represents a very different approach to older, wellestablished systems of evaluation such as the World Heritage Convention or Natura2000, covering areas of land designated nationally or regionally for a particular value (for example for their scenic, heritage or wildlife value). Under such systems, a cultural landscape is not any place that people have altered but specific places that demonstrate the highest achievements of human beings or are judged to have particular significance. It is a top-down, largely single-sector approach, driven by elites based on disciplinary expert advice but also marketing potential. Its primary tool is designation, which immediately implies undesignated areas.

The HERCULES Project was also interested in heritage. Therefore, it is worth considering the concept of Cultural Landscapes as described within the World Heritage Convention (WHC). At least four different concepts of landscape can be disentangled here: one stems from garden history, where a landscape is a large designed landscape; another comes from historical geography and archaeology, to be a palimpsest of the past, judged on its historical transparency; a third comes from art history and could be a picture on a wall, or a film; and a fourth comes from ecology and is defined by the scale of an ecosystem.

Why are we advocating a landscape approach in policy?

The concepts of landscape within the ELC and the WHC are very different and, in their systems of governance and designation, are not easy to reconcile. Much of current environmental governance arises from the application of ‘administrative rationality’, based on the application of expert advice by administrators. In contrast, the ELC approach is overtly participative, where policies are based on deliberation informed by experts as well as the knowledge and opinions of lay people, stakeholders and citizens.

We advocate such a participative, transdisciplinary i.e. landscape approach to governance because it avoids the pitfalls of single-sector or single-discipline approaches. These tend to produce solutions that are rapidly undermined by lack of wider acceptance, by developments within other aspects of landscapes or by unforeseen events. Therefore, sustainable solutions to the challenges arising in relation to the environments in which we live are more likely to flow from a landscape approach. But before a wider constituency of stakeholders can participate, an appropriate landscape governance framework must be developed by governments and public authorities. The document aims to guide this process.

To read the recommendations click here >>

 

Tell Us What You Think:

The information and views set out in this Cultural Landscapes Blog are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the HERCULES project nor the European Commission.

Blog Search

Blog Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by e-mail:

Blog Archive

Tags

, CAP, Cultural Landscape Days, Cultural Landscapes, Cultural heritage, Cultural landscape values, Cultural landscapes, EFAs, ELC, EU level workshop, EU project, EU-funded project, Estonia, European Landscape Convention, European review, HERCULES project, HERCULEs, Knowledge Hub, LIFE+, Lakescape, Land use, Landscape Initiatives, Marine ecosystem, PECSRL, The Bonn Challenge, WHC, WP1, WP3, WP4, World Forest Congress, abandonment, agent-based landscape change model, agrarian landscapes, agricultural landscapes, agriculture landscapes, ancient, anthropology, archaeological site;, archaeology, biodiversity, case studies, case study, citizens, climate change, coastal ecosystem, collaborative project, community plan, cross-disciplinary, cultural capital, cultural heritage, cultural landscape change, cultural landscape typology, cultural landscape values, cultural landscapes, cultural landscapes; driving forces; ecosystem services; landscape management; socio-cultural valuation, culture, data repository, dialogue, diversity, driving forces, dynamics of change, ecological space, ecosystem services, enhancing knowledge, farmland consolidation, field boundarie, field margins, fieldwork, food, foodscapes, forest landscape restoration, forest science, forestry, free access, good management practices, greening, habitat management, heritage, heritage categorisation, heritage inventory, heritage objects, historic ships, historical ecology, human element, human well-being, ice-roads, integrated landscape initiatives, inter- and transdisciplinary integration, knowledge, labelling, land cover, land use, land-use change, landscape, landscape approach, landscape assessment, landscape change, landscape community, landscape development, landscape features, landscape governance, landscape history, landscape labelling, landscape management, landscape policies, landscape preservation, landscape resilience, landscape stewardship, landscape values, landscapes, landscapes art, local, local benefits, local initiative, local natural heritage, local scale workhop, local stakeholder engagement, local supply, long-term changes, management, mapping tool, methods, monument, national landscape, natural capital, ong-term landscape history; landscape change; landscape values; landscape stewardship, oral history, peri-urbanization, photo contest, policies, policy, pond area, prioritization exercise, procedure, reconciling interest, recreational activity, research, research project, restoration, results, revitalization, rural development, scenario, social functions, stakeholder collaboration, stakeholder engagement, stewardship, stewardship goals, stewardship; connectivity; ecological integrity and human wellbeing; ecosystem services, sustainability, synthesis, traditional and local knowledge, web GIS, well-being, wild food, wood-pastures, workshop
Back to top
Hercules Project © 2018 - All rights reserved
created by WebDeb